How closely is the health of the spine connected to the health of the rest of the body?
That question has intrigued chiropractors since the profession’s earliest days. It also motivated an investigation by physician Henry Winsor, whose autopsy findings are still discussed in chiropractic circles more than a century later.spinalcheckfoundation+1
The story is worth exploring. But to understand its significance, we need to distinguish what Winsor observed from what those observations could actually establish.
First, a Little Historical Context
Chiropractic’s beginnings are traditionally traced to 1895, when D.D. Palmer treated Harvey Lillard. In testimony later published in Palmer’s journal, Lillard reported that his hearing improved after two spinal treatments. That account became central to the profession’s founding story; it is a historical report, not a controlled demonstration that spinal adjustments treat hearing loss.library.palmer
Winsor’s investigation came later. Rather than documenting chiropractic’s discovery, it explored a question that interested early practitioners: could abnormalities in the spine be associated with disease elsewhere in the body?staywellstcharles
What Was Winsor Investigating?
In work published in The Medical Times in 1921, Winsor examined cadavers for relationships between spinal curvatures and diseased internal organs. His stated aim was to determine whether a connection existed between those findings.staywellstcharles
He focused on sympathetic nerve segments—the nerve pathways considered in his analysis—and whether diseased organs corresponded to the same segments as the observed spinal curvatures.staywellstcharles
In other words, he was looking for an anatomical association.
That distinction matters: observing two findings together is different from showing that one caused the other.
What Did He Report?
One frequently cited passage reports 221 diseased structures outside the spine. Of those, 212 were described as belonging to the same sympathetic segments as the vertebrae involved in a curvature. The remaining nine were assigned to different segments.spinalcheckfoundation+1
That is approximately 96% correspondence within the reported observations—a striking figure, and one reason the study continues to attract attention.snyderfamilychiro
But the meaning of that number depends on what was being counted.
It describes a reported relationship between anatomical findings in cadavers. It does not describe the percentage of patients who improved with chiropractic care, and it does not establish that a spinal curvature caused an organ’s disease.
Winsor also acknowledged that the segmental relationships were not simple: an organ could receive sympathetic nerve fibers from several spinal segments, and one segment could contribute fibers to several organs.staywellstcharles
What the Autopsies Could Not Tell Us
An autopsy can document what is present at death. By itself, it cannot establish the sequence in which those findings developed.
Consequently, the reported correspondence does not answer several important questions:
Did the spinal changes develop before the organ disease?
Did one contribute to the other?
Could another factor explain both findings?
Would changing the spine improve the organ’s condition?
Most importantly, this was an autopsy investigation—not a trial of chiropractic treatment. It did not demonstrate that adjustments reversed the reported diseases or prevented them from developing.spinalcheckfoundation+1
The findings raised a question. They did not settle it.
How Does This Fit With Today’s Evidence?
Historical observations can inspire research, but treatment claims need evidence from studies of living patients.
According to the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, only a small amount of high-quality research has examined spinal manipulation for conditions outside the musculoskeletal system. A comprehensive 2021 review identified six studies of high or acceptable quality, involving 534 participants, on nonmusculoskeletal conditions such as high blood pressure and menstrual cramps. None showed a clear benefit from spinal manipulation.nccih.nih
The evidence picture is different for spine-related pain. A recent review of clinical practice guidelines found that most guidelines considering spinal manipulation recommended it for low-back pain and neck pain, although recommendations depend on the condition and clinical circumstances.pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih
These are separate claims. Evidence supporting care for back or neck pain should not be extended into a promise to treat kidney disease, thyroid disorders, heart disease, or other internal-organ conditions.
Why the Winsor Story Still Matters
Winsor’s work illustrates a question that helped shape early chiropractic thinking: how might findings in the spine relate to findings elsewhere in the body?staywellstcharles
We can appreciate that curiosity without treating a century-old anatomical investigation as the final word.
For me, the useful lesson is that curiosity and careful reasoning belong together. We can take spinal health seriously, remain interested in the body’s interconnectedness, and still be precise about what the evidence does—and does not—show.
The Winsor autopsies belong in chiropractic’s historical conversation. Their value is strongest when we present them as observations that prompted questions, rather than as proof of benefits they never tested.


